Reproductive Health Matters
Volume 17, Issue 34 , Pages 154-162 , November 2009

Vertical HIV transmission should be excluded from criminal prosecution

  • Joanne Csete

      Affiliations

    • Associate Clinical Professor, Heilbrunn Department of Population and Family Health, Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, New York NY, USA
    • ,
  • Richard Pearshouse

      Affiliations

    • Senior Researcher, Human Rights Watch, New York NY, USA
    • ,
  • Alison Symington

      Affiliations

    • Senior Policy Analyst, Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, Toronto ONT, Canada

References 

  1. World Health Organization. Priority interventions: HIV prevention, treatment and care in the health sector (version 1.2). Geneva, 2009, p 28. At: <http://www.who.int/hiv/pub/priority_interventions_web_c1.pdf>.
  2. International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. UN General Assembly res. 2200A (XXI), 1966, articles 15(1) and 12.
  3. Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, UN General Assembly res. 34/180, 1979, article 16(e).
  4. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. UN General Assembly res. 2200A (XXI), 1966, article 23(2).
  5. World Health OrganizationUN Population FundJoint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS)International Planned Parenthood Federation. Sexual and reproductive health and HIV/AIDS: a framework for priority linkages, 2005. At: < www.who.int/reproductive-health/stis/docs/framework_priority_linkages.pdf>
  6. Global Network of People Living with AIDS (GNP+). Global Criminalisation Scan. at: < http://www.gnpplus.net/criminalisation/>
  7. Bernard EJ. Criminal HIV transmission (archived blog). at: < http://criminalhivtransmission.blogspot.com/>
  8. Bray SJ. Criminal prosecutions for HIV exposure: overview and analysis. Center for Interdisciplinary Research on AIDS Working Paper 3(1). New Haven: Yale University; 2003;At: < http://cira.med.yale.edu/law_policy_ethics/criminal_pros.pdf>
  9. WHO, UNAIDS, UNICEF. Towards universal access: scaling up priority HIV/AIDS interventions in the health sector – Progress report 2008. At: < www.who.int/hiv/mediacentre/universal_access_progress_report_en.pdf>
  10. International Treatment Preparedness Coalition. Missing the target (no. 7): failing women, failing children: HIV, vertical transmission and women’s health. New York, 2009. At: < www.aidstreatmentaccess.org/mtt7_final.pdf>
  11. Chinkonde JR, Sundby J, Martinson F, et al. The prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission programme in Lilongwe, Malawi: why do so many women drop out?. Reproductive Health Matters. 2009;17(33):143–151
  12. Medley A, Garcia-Moreno C, McGill S, et al. Rates, barriers and outcomes of HIV serostatus disclosure among women in developing countries: implications for prevention of mother-to-child transmission programmes. Bulletin of World Health Organization. 2004;82(4):299–307
  13. WHOUNAIDS. Guidance on provider-initiated HIV testing and counseling in health facilities. Geneva, 2007. At: < www.who.int/hiv/pub/guidelines/9789241595568_en.pdf>
  14. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, UNAIDS. HIV/AIDS and Human Rights: International Guidelines. UN Doc. No.HR/PUB/06.9, 2006 (first issued 1998).
  15. GNP+, Terrence Higgins Trust. Criminalisation of HIV transmission in Europe: a rapid scan of the laws and rates of prosecution for HIV transmission within signatory states of the European Convention of Human Rights, 2005. At: < www.gnpplus.net/criminalisation/rapidscan.pdf>
  16. Stackpool-Moore L. Verdict on a virus: public health, human rights and criminal law, London: IPPF, GNP+ and International Community of Women Living with HIV/AIDS, 2008. At: < www.ippf.org/NR/rdonlyres/D858DFB2-19CD-4483-AEC9-1B1C5EBAF48A/0/VerdictOnAVirus.pdf>
  17. Centers for Disease Control. Transmission of HIV possibly associated with exposure of mucous membrane to contaminated blood. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. 1997;46:620–623
  18. Pearshouse R. Legislation contagion: building resistance. HIV/AIDS Policy and Law Review 2008;13(2/3):1,5–10
  19. UNAIDS. Criminalization of HIV transmission (policy brief). Geneva, 2008. At: < http://data.unaids.org/pub/BaseDocument/2008/20080731_jc1513_policy_criminalization_en.pdf>
  20. Burris S, Cameron E. The case against criminalization of HIV transmission. JAMA. 2008;300:578–581
  21. USAID. AWARE-HIV/AIDS, 2003–2008: Strengthening West Africa’s response to the epidemic. Washington DC, 2009. At: < www.fhi.org/NR/rdonlyres/e75cohbsjbrlscw777qkkj66y5sucru4k76dnzssfokgphw2n6zsbbelxtmxod2usqx37k6cawewra/AWARECloseoutReportHV.pdf>
  22. Action for West Africa Region HIV/AIDS Project (AWARE-HIV/AIDS). Regional Workshop to Adopt a Model Law for STI/HIV/AIDS for West and Central Africa: General Report, 2004. [on file with authors]
  23. Pearshouse R. Legislation contagion: the spread of problematic new HIV laws in Western Africa. HIV/AIDS Policy and Law Review 20008;12(2/3):1, 5–11.
  24. USAID. Success Story: A Specific Law on HIV/AIDS (on-line newsletter), 2005. At: < www.fhi.org/NR/rdonlyres/eih2fipgyy4qxbpac5vw3qgvvp2dqunpkhdemepkub2qkok33gmj2mwt4bn4pltlasi4xhntqcfj4h/SUCCESSSTORYBENIN2enhv.pdf>
  25. R. v. Cuerrier, [1998] 2 SCR 371; R. v. Williams, [2003] 2 SCR 134.
  26. Lazzarini Z, Bray S, Burris S. Evaluating the impact of criminal laws on HIV risk behavior. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics. 2002;30:239–253
  27. Wolf LE, Vezina R. Crime and punishment: is there a role for criminal law in HIV prevention policy?. Whittier Law Review. 2004;25:821–886
  28. A human rights analysis of the N’Djamena model legislation on AIDS and HIV-specific legislation in Benin, Guinea, Guinea Bissau, Mali, Niger, Sierra Leone and Togo. Toronto: Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network; 2007;[on file with authors]
  29. Republic of Sierra Leone. Prevention and Control of HIV and AIDS Act, 2007. Government Gazette No.28, 7 June 2007.
  30. République de Guinée. Loi relative à la prévention, la prise en charge et le contrôle du VIH/Sida, L/2005/025/AN, 2005.
  31. Republic of Zimbabwe. Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act [Chapter 9:23], Act 23/2004. At: < www.kubatana.net/docs/legisl/criminal_law_code_050603.pdf>
  32. Cameron E. HIV is a virus, not a crime: criminal states and criminal prosecutions – help or hindrance? Presentation to the XVII International AIDS Conference, Mexico City, 13 August 2008. Available at: <www.tac.org.za/community/node/2399>.
  33. HIV/AIDS Management and Prevention Act, Papua New Guinea (No. 4 of 2003), s.22.
  34. Southern Africa Development Community Parliamentary Forum. Model law on HIV and AIDS in Southern Africa, 2008. At: < www.sadccitizen.net/SADC/new/hivaids/downloads/SADC%20PF%20Model%20law%20on%20HIV%20November%202008%20final.pdf>
  35. Paltrow LM. Punishing women for their behavior during pregnancy: an approach that undermines the health of women and children. New York: Center for Reproductive Rights, 2000. At: < http://reproductiverights.org/sites/default/files/documents/pub_bp_punishingwomen.pdf>
  36. Manatee boy has AIDS: mother charged. Bradenton Herald. 11 January 2008, p.1.
  37. Scarcella MA. Officials: woman with HIV didn’t seek care for baby. Herald Tribune. 11 January 2008, p.BCE1.
  38. National Advocates for Pregnant Women. Bail granted for imprisoned HIV-positive pregnant woman in Maine (blog), 2009. At: < http://advocatesforpregnantwomen.org/blog/>
  39. Six-month conditional sentence for mother who hid HIV status for son’s birth. HIV/AIDS Policy and Law Review. 2006;11(2/3):45
  40. Coovadia HM, Rollins NC, Bland RM, et al. Mother-to-child transmission of HIV-1 infection during exclusive breastfeeding in the first 6 months of life: an intervention cohort study. Lancet. 2007;369(9567):1107–1116
  41. de Paoli MM, Manongi R, Klepp K-I. Counsellors’ perspectives on antenatal HIV testing and infant feeding dilemmas facing women with HIV in northern Tanzania. Reproductive Health Matters. 2002;10(20):144–156
  42. World Health Organization. Consensus statement from the WHO HIV and infant feeding technical consultation. Geneva, 2006. At: <www.who.int/child_adolescent_health/documents/if_consensus/en/index.html>.
  43. Bond V, Chase E, Aggleton P. Stigma, HIV/AIDS and prevention of mother-to-child transmission in Zambia. Evaluation and Programme Planning. 2002;25(4):347–356
  44. Center for Reproductive Rights, Federation of Women Lawyers of Kenya. At risk: rights violations of HIV-positive women in Kenyan health facilities. New York, 2008. At: < http://reproductiverights.org/sites/default/files/documents/At%20Risk.pdf>
  45. Epstein H. In: The Invisible Cure: Africa, the West and the fight against AIDS. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux; 2007;p. 269–270
  46. de Bruyn M. Reproductive choice and women living with HIV/AIDS. Chapel Hill NC: Ipas; 2002;At: < www.genderandaids.org/downloads/topics/Repro_Choice_HIV_AIDS.pdf>
  47. Tjaronda W. Forced sterilisation victims seek redress. New Era, 17 February 2009. At: < www.lac.org.na/news/inthenews/archive/2009/news-20090217.html>

PII: S0968-8080(09)34468-7

doi: 10.1016/S0968-8080(09)34468-7

Reproductive Health Matters
Volume 17, Issue 34 , Pages 154-162 , November 2009

Article Tools